No TDS on discount given to Stamp Vendors for purchasing stamps in bulk quantity0 comments Tuesday, September 11, 2012The assessee, an association of stamp vendors, bought stamps from the State Govt. at a discount. The department claimed that the stamp vendors were “agents” of the State Govt. and that the said discount was “commission or brokerage” and the State Govt. ought to deduct TDS u/s 194H. The assessee filed a Writ Petition to challenge the department’s action. The Gujarat High Court upheld the assessee’s plea that (a) title in the stamps passed to the vendors and that they were not “agents” of the State Govt. but were transacting on a “principal to principal” basis and (b) the discount available to the stamp vendors was not “commission or brokerage” so as to fall within s. 194H. On appeal by the department to the Supreme Court, HELD dismissing the appeal: Lower/Nil rate of tax deduction certificate for works contractors under Punjab VAT Act, 20050 comments
It is ussualy seen that works contractors registered under
Punjab VAT Act, 2005 have always refund to claim from the Excise & Taxation
department due to the fact that their final tax liability is much lower/Nil
than the tax deductions made u/s 27 of Punjab VAT Act, 2005. It results in
blocking of their working capital till the time they get refund from the
Department.The solution to it is to resort to section 27(10) of Punjab VAT Act,
2005.
The relevant provisions of PVAT Act 2005 and certain relevant judgements have been discussed herebelow in this regard
Subscribe to:
Posts
(
Atom
)
Featured PostTCS to apply only on cash portion of sales transaction CBDT clarifiesWelcome clarification by CBDT on TCS on Cash Sale. CBDT vide Circular No. 23/2016 dt. 24 June 2016 has clarified on FAQs of stakeholde... AddThisShareThisGet updates via email, just subscribe below and click on activation link afterwards in your emailCategory
Right consultancy at right time avoids unnecessary litigation.
Popular Posts
FollowersAbout Me
FeedjitBlog Archive
WARNING
Nobody is permitted to copy or publish the articles existing on this blog on any website or on any other media without my express permission. Total PageviewsDisclaimer
No one is responsible for any claims if somebody finds that the information/opinions provided in this blog is incorrect and the blog is meant only to share knowledge and exchange views in a meaningful manner.
Useful Links
Powered by Blogger.
|